fresh no ads
Talent and toughness | Philstar.com
^

Arts and Culture

Talent and toughness

PENMAN - Butch Dalisay -
I was in Baguio last week for the start of the 44th UP National Writers Workshop, and once again we gathered and met about 20 of the country’s best young writers in English, Filipino, and other Philippine languages. The Baguio workshop – held this year at the Inn Rocio, which used to be the home of the late great Chino Roces – is an annual rite of passage for aspiring Filipino writers, and over the past four decades it has helped produce most of our finest fictionists, poets, dramatists, and essayists.

But creative writing, because of its nature and of the few material rewards it offers (at least in this country), also has one of the highest attrition rates as a discipline. I often begin my CW classes – especially at the undergraduate level, where I can still meet people just starting out as writers – that in a typical class of 20 students, we’d be lucky to find three or four with the talent and one or two with the toughness to keep on writing and writing well for the rest of their lives. Talent and toughness – you need both to survive and prosper as a creative writer (indeed, as any kind of artist), especially in a society that doesn’t take kindly to serious art and artmaking.

That’s not to say that creative writing class will be a waste of time for those with neither of these qualities. I’m convinced that every person has at least one story to tell, and that it will be achievement enough for both mentor and student to get that person to write that story, beyond which he or she can move on to a more promising career in accounting, pharmacy, investment banking, or aquaculture. (And let’s not forget that many good writers never went to writing school, but were, in fact, physicians, clerks, and soldiers.)

Even at the Baguio workshop, it was hard to tell from those soft, earnest faces how many of them would be producing books of literary worth 10, 15 years hence. Having been culled from an initial list of 125 applicants, these fellows already manifested a certain level of raw talent, so the rest will largely be up to them, to their brains and their guts – with a little help from teachers like us.

Our first workshop activity is always a statement from each panelist about what we look for in creative work. This was the wish list I gave the workshoppers:

1) Competence, if not brilliance, in language;

2) Fresh, interesting, and significant ideas;

3) A feel for form – both intuitive and learned; and

4) Risk-taking.

I’ll discuss these in greater detail in some future column.
* * *
While up in Baguio, I heard of a proposal being floated around by some people involved with the National Artist Awards – due to be given out early next year, if I’m not mistaken – which would bar also-rans from consideration for, say, 10 years, and only upon giving proof of new achievements. In other words, if you lost this year to someone like Edith Tiempo or the late Jose Joya, you’d have to wait a while – a long while – before your nomination can be revived.

I think I understand where the idea comes from, which is probably to spare the NAA committee (committees, actually, at least at the initial stage, formed according to genre) from having to consider the same old nominations that keep getting submitted every NAA season while refreshing the roster of possible National Artists. It would also spare the perennial losers from humiliation.

On second thought, however, I see more problems than advantages with this proposal, which will only ensure that third-raters – including political appointees – will have an easier time becoming National Artists. By shelving your second-rank nominees (who often include first-rate artists who could not be accommodated in the current batch for budgetary or even political reasons), you leave yourself no option but to open the door to names so obscure and unaccomplished that no one had even thought of the first time around. How smart is that? Besides, making people wait 10 years or even six years for their next turn would be a form of cruel and unusual punishment; with National Artists usually receiving that distinction only in their 60s or 70s – or from the grave – a few years could literally mean the difference between life and death.

What we need in the NAA selection process are more explicit guarantees against political appointments – especially by tenants of the Palace whose understanding of art could fit on a napkin – to secure the integrity and credibility of the awards. While we’re at it, we should speed up the formation of a National Academy of Arts and Letters, from which future National Artists could more naturally emerge.
* * *
By the time you read this, I should be somewhere over the Pacific, accompanying my mom to my sister in Virginia, where I’ll be imbibing the spring air (hard work, but someone’s got to do it) for a couple of weeks. Our very strange routing (courtesy of my mom’s free frequent-flyer ticket) requires us to spend 12 hours in Guam and another 12 hours in Houston before flying on to DC. I’ve never been to either Guam or Houston; all I know about Guam is that it has more snakes than you can put on Fear Factor, and when I think of Houston all I can say is that "Houston, we have a problem." Watch out for my reportage of that most exciting of human adventures, the 12-hour layover.

Speaking of the United States, another professional organization I’m proud to be associated with is the Philippine Fulbright Scholars Association, which represents the nearly 2,000 Filipinos fortunate enough to have had their advanced studies and graduate degrees underwritten in the US by the Fulbright program, now on its 57th year. Some of the most productive and momentous years of my writing life were my Fulbright years (Michigan 1986-88, Wisconsin 1988-91), and so I’ve resolved to give something back by serving on the board of the PFSA, which held its general assembly early last month at Ateneo-Rockwell with former President Cory Aquino and US Ambassador Francis Ricciardone as guests of honor.

These are very interesting – indeed, trying – times for Philippine-American relations, with many of us who acknowledge a personal debt of gratitude to the US for our education having nevertheless to disagree with current US foreign policy in many places around the world, including the Philippines. (I can just see the flood of e-mail that comment’s going to spark among Dubya’s fans here and on the West Coast. Save your breath, folks; I learned forthrightness, not docility, in America.) Initiatives like the Fulbright, Hubert Humphrey, and East-West Center programs remind us that the best international relations are often person-to-person and people-to-people ones, not the self-serving accommodations that politicians and businessmen have to accord each other.

The PFSA’s new board of directors is a roster of what to many of our readers will be very familiar names: DLSU professor and STAR columnist Isagani Cruz, president; UP professor Dondon Paderanga, vice president; Silliman University professor Angel Alcala, VP for Visayas and Mindanao; Yuchengco Group legal counsel Macel Fernandez-Estavillo, secretary; UP and Ateneo mass communications lecturer Chi-Chi Robles, treasurer; UP mass comm professor Betsy Enriquez, auditor; and myself, PRO. Other board members include Adarna House’s Ani Almario; Mowelfund head and film director Nick Deocampo; former PAEF chief Johnny Francisco; business leader Oscar Hilado; AIM professor Poch Macaranas; Ateneo president Fr. Bienvenido Nebres; historian Ambeth Ocampo; and former Senator Rene Saguisag.

I don’t think I can complain about the company I keep here.
* * *
Send e-mail to Butch Dalisay at penmanila@yahoo.com.

ADARNA HOUSE

AMBASSADOR FRANCIS RICCIARDONE

AMBETH OCAMPO

ANGEL ALCALA

ANI ALMARIO

ATENEO

BETSY ENRIQUEZ

BIENVENIDO NEBRES

FULBRIGHT

NATIONAL ARTISTS

Are you sure you want to log out?
X
Login

Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!

Get Updated:

Signup for the News Round now

FORGOT PASSWORD?
SIGN IN
or sign in with