Hontiveros corrects claim on Supreme Court 'League of Cities' vote

MANILA, Philippines — Sen. Risa Hontiveros corrected herself after citing a Supreme Court en banc case as a unanimous decision later overturned, acknowledging that several rulings in the case were not unanimous.
This was the League of Cities of the Philippines vs. Commission on Elections dispute, which went through six decisions between 2008 and 2011, with the high court repeatedly reversing itself and granting motions for reconsideration.
"Upon checking again, the many reversals in the League of Cities decisions were not decided unanimously," she said in a Facebook post on Thursday night, August 7.
Hontiveros named the case as an example where all participating justices voted unanimously, only for the decision to be reversed after a motion for reconsideration.
She raised this as a point of information during the Senate’s plenary session on August 6, disputing Sen. Rodante Marcoleta’s statement that such reversals have not happened before.
During that session, senators deliberated on the motion to dismiss Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment, taking into account the Supreme Court’s unanimous decision declaring her impeachment unconstitutional.
RELATED: Hontiveros disputes Marcoleta: SC can overturn unanimous rulings
An honest mistake?
The complication with the League of Cities vs. Comelec case lies in conflicting records of how the justices voted.
Lawphil, a widely used and accessible online library of court decisions, shows no indication of dissent in its copy of the November 2008 ruling, suggesting that all 15 justices concurred in declaring the cityhood laws unconstitutional.
Two lawyers consulted by Philstar.com, however, noted that based on the jurisprudence libraries they reviewed, it was the December 2009 decision — not the 2008 ruling — that was unanimous.
That 2009 decision was later overturned in 2010, which would support the argument that a unanimous Supreme Court ruling had been reversed — if not for the possibility that these legal libraries had erred in publishing the votes of justices.
Checking the Supreme Court E-Library, however, shows that none of the six decisions issued in the case were unanimous, although it also contained discrepancies between the voting details in its text format and those in the attached PDF copies.
The Supreme Court also issued a statement on Thursday confirming that the League of Cities vs. Comelec case had no unanimous decisions and urged the public to rely on the E-Library as the official source.
Argument still stands
After issuing her clarification, Hontiveros maintained that her point still stands. The Supreme Court en banc has, in the past, reversed a unanimous decision.
This was evident in the second case she cited, which was the International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-Biotech Applications, Inc. vs. Greenpeace Southeast Asia (Philippines), where participating justices decided unanimously in 2015 but overturned in 2016 upon a motion for reconsideration filed by the petitioners.
"This is a reminder that no one is immune from error. The most important thing is to correct it," Hontiveros said in her post.
Lawyer Dino de Leon, in a Facebook post on Friday, August 8, also argued that Hontiveros’ explanation “nonetheless points out that the Supreme Court can change its mind numerous times,” as the League of Cities case reversed itself multiple times across six decisions.
Impeachment archived
The Senate shelved the articles of impeachment on August 6, voting 19-4-1 in favor of Marcoleta's amended motion to archive the complaint instead of "dismissing" it. The motion was made based on the Supreme Court's ruling that the Senate has no jurisdiction over Duterte's impeachment.
Before the Senate acted, however, the House had already filed a motion for reconsideration before the Supreme Court, seeking to overturn the ruling on the grounds that it was based on misstated facts. In other words, the high court's decision is not yet final as it has been appealed.
Still, the Senate majority voted to archive the impeachment rather than wait for the Supreme Court’s final ruling, arguing that the articles could be “retrieved” from the archives if necessary. It would, however, be subject to another vote.
RELATED: Sara Duterte's impeachment archived: Senate 'adheres' to Supreme Court ruling
- Latest
- Trending



























