Not over until it is
Given how survey after survey declares the daunting numbers that supporters of Leni Robredo must overcome, it is easy to understand their joy over the news that Google Trends seems to indicate they have taken the lead. Google Trends was also said to have predicted election winners.
I wish it was as simple as that. True, it did indicate winners in some elections, but not in others. Here is the abstract of a study made by an Indonesian academic comparing Google Trends with actual vote numbers:
“In electoral competitions, voter behavior research is conducted to develop effective campaign strategies, but survey methods tend to be expensive. By contrast, in the internet era political campaigns evolve by using digital data and channels.
“Google Trends offers free services that display search interest indexes for certain keywords and topics measured through search volumes on Google search engines over a period of time and certain areas.
“Thus, Google Trends could be a tool that increases the efficiency of voter behavior research. By using the election real count data released by the General Election Commission on May 21, 2019, this study conducted an accuracy and precision analysis of the Google Trends topic query index that represented presidential candidate number 01 and number 02 in predicting the real count of the two candidates’ votes.
“The analysis indicated that using Google Trends as a tool to predict the results of the 2019 Indonesian Presidential Election produced imprecise results. However, Google Trends could better predict election outcomes by adding features for sentiment analysis and a more representative understanding of users’ search activity.”
I asked Google Philippines about the meaning of Google Trends tracking for our election this May. They cautioned that “The Google Trends Philippine Elections is not a poll or a survey and does not reflect voting intentions. It merely reflects people’s search interest about particular topics at a local level over a period of time. A spike in a particular search query does not reflect that a candidate is somehow ‘popular’ or ‘winning’.”
What is Google Trends?
Google Trends is a tool that shows how frequently a given search term is entered into Google’s search engine relative to the site’s total search volume over a given period of time. It has some predictive qualities, but it depends on how a researcher frames keywords for the search engine to look out for.
For instance, during the COVID-19 pandemic, Google has made its data on search trends to do with COVID-19 symptoms public. The data was primarily made up of the volume of searches of over 400 symptoms, signs, and health conditions.
Theoretically, the data could show an uptick in cases, even before an outbreak has been detected in an area and can help epidemiologists track hotspots. That helps public health officials allocate resources.
Before COVID, if a flu season is expected to be particularly severe in a certain area based on Google Trends data, it might get more vaccines, more hospital beds, and more resources to fight the outbreak.
But experts say there are some risks basing those decisions on Google Trends alone. Epidemiologically speaking, public health experts consider Google Trends most useful when it is used together with other information in a predictive model.
A World Economic Forum post says Google Trends doesn’t always match up to the real-world data. In 2013, Google Trends anticipated a huge national spike in flu cases that simply never happened.
It was explained that widespread media coverage of a severe US flu season, including the declaration of a public-health emergency by New York state might have thrown the algorithm off, prompting “many flu-related searches by people who were not ill.”
WEF observes: “No one — not even Google — is suggesting that Google Trends is proven enough to replace existing epidemiological models.”
The Google Trends report that gave the Leni-Kiko team a morale boost merely showed that Leni topped the number of searches on the basis of keywords. It also seemed to have assumed that the searches are all indicative of positive sentiment, which may not be the case.
Keywords associated with a name are classified as either positive or negative. As an example – a mention of Leni and female/woman may have been set up as a positive indicator of sentiment. BUT it may have been mentioned in a sexist context and should have been classified as negative.
I am not sure if they used sentiment analysis, which would make the report more useful. Sentiment analysis looks at the emotion expressed in a text. Experts will tell you that everything depends on how values for positive and negative indicators are set up for the algorithms to determine sentiment.
Sentiment analysis is also known as “opinion mining” or “emotion artificial intelligence.” A key aspect of sentiment analysis is polarity classification.
As explained by getthematic.com, polarity refers to the overall sentiment conveyed by a particular text, phrase or word. This polarity can be expressed as a numerical rating known as a “sentiment score”. For example, this score can be a number between -100 and 100 with 0 representing neutral sentiment.
Then there is this report that Leni is now leading in terms of Facebook engagement score. Not sure what this really means… or if it could, as claimed, help predict potential voters of a candidate.
The story does not even say if the engagement they measured is all positive because it could also mean negative, given the widespread use of trolls. At most, this could mean high name recall or hopefully for Leni’s handlers, a high propensity to consider Leni’s candidacy.
Google Trends and sentiment analysis of Facebook and Twitter posts provide a real time picture that helps decision making. But old fashioned surveys done well will not be replaced by Google Trends anytime soon.
This all means it isn’t over until it is… still too early to relax. There are about 50 days more of hard work. The Google and Facebook stories should energize Leni’s team to work harder because victory is now possible and the situation is not as dim as the traditional surveys seem to indicate.
Boo Chanco’s email address is [email protected]. Follow him on Twitter @boochanco
- Latest
- Trending


























