Tax deadline for BBM
Tax evasion didn’t stop Ferdinand Marcos Jr. from running for president, and winning the post by the largest margin ever (thanks to technology, according to critics).
Four years into his term, President Marcos is on track to attain his objective of securing the dismissal of all the cases involving his family’s fantabulous unexplained wealth.
These are spectacular victories for the Marcos clan.
So perhaps BBM should give the nation at least one win during his watch, by paying the massive estate tax that the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) has been trying to collect from him and his family (at least before he assumed power).
Civil society coalition 1Sambayan has warned that the BIR has only until Dec. 2 to collect that tax, originally P23 billion when the deficiency was assessed in 1991, but which has ballooned to an estimated P203 billion from penalties and surcharges as of December 2021.
If new BIR Commissioner Rolando Ligon Jr. fails to meet that deadline for prescription of the collection of such a huge amount of taxes, he may be charged with dereliction of duty and dismissed from government.
The charges may include Ligon’s predecessors, Charlito Mendoza, who served as BIR chief for a year from November last year, and Romeo Lumagui Jr., who occupied the post for three years from November 2022.
I once asked Benjamin Diokno if he, while serving as BBM’s first finance secretary, would direct the BIR to collect the estate tax. He asked, rather grumpily, why the burden should fall on him.
* * *
Perhaps BBM is worried that paying the estate tax would confirm his clan’s ginormous wealth, which cannot all be attributed to the lost treasure of Japanese World War II Gen. Tomoyuki Yamashita and the Tallano royal family’s gold bullions combined.
The enormity of that wealth and its illicit nature were already legally established in an en banc ruling of the Supreme Court in 2003. The SC declared that from 1966 until their ouster in 1986, Ferdinand Sr. and wife Imelda legitimately earned only $304,372 from their salaries as public officials, and all funds exceeding that lawful income constituted ill-gotten wealth that must be returned to the state.
On the basis of this ruling, the Swiss Federal Supreme Court ordered the return to the Philippines of deposits held in Swiss banks by the Marcos couple using bogus foundations.
In March 1968, the opening deposit of “William Saunders” and “Jane Ryan” in Credit Suisse in Zurich was $950,000 – already way above the $304,372. By the time the deposits were released to the Philippines, the amount had grown to around $683 million.
This year, a division of the SC went against that en banc ruling to reverse the Sandiganbayan’s conviction of Imeldific on seven counts of graft. The division ruling was partly based on the argument that the documents on the foundations – the same ones accepted by the SC in the 2003 en banc case – lacked authentication.
The ponente or author of this fantastic (for the Marcoses) ruling is Rodil Zalameda, who was recently promoted by BBM to Chief Justice.
Zalameda also authored the SC en banc ruling (unanimous, we have to note) that tax evasion is not an offense constituting moral turpitude, for which conviction could have disqualified BBM from running for president in 2022.
While BBM was not yet in power at the time, he was the standard bearer of the UniTeam backed by the Duterte administration, with his running mate Inday Sara the daughter of the person in power, Rodrigo Duterte.
BBM’s candidacy was challenged on the basis of his conviction for tax evasion by the Quezon City Regional Trial Court in 1995 for failure to pay his income tax and file his tax returns from 1982 to 1985.
The Court of Appeals cleared BBM in 1997 of failure to pay the taxes, but convicted him for failure to file his tax returns. He was fined P36,000 and ordered to pay the deficiency taxes, with interest, but the prison term of up to nine years imposed by the QC court was dropped.
BBM appealed this ruling before the SC, but withdrew the appeal in 2001, making it final and executory. In June 2022, the SC dismissed the challenge to BBM’s candidacy based on this tax case. His camp said he had paid the tax dues in full, although the QC court said it was unaware of this.
* * *
The bigger issue, of course, is the P23 billion in estate tax, now ballooned to an estimated P203 billion. The SC upheld the BIR’s collection effort in 1997.
Any government would want to collect such a huge amount in revenues. It would have been a source of pride for Charlito Mendoza to have collected such a large amount, especially since the order for payment already became final and executory.
Any government, that is, except the one led by the person being ordered to pay the taxes.
BBM and his wife are both lawyers with links to law firms, so he’s surely aware of the prescription period for collecting the estate tax. Inevitably, his supposed neglect of his civic duty as a taxpayer is fueling suspicions that he is deliberately waiting for that collection period to prescribe.
In August this year, BBM said he has been too busy with the demands of the presidency to attend to the estate tax case. Matters of state and governance, he said, are “a thousand times more important” than his role as co-executor (together with mom Imeldific) of his father’s estate.
This is leadership by bad example, which could fuel a tax boycott. If the President of the Republic is evading tax payment, why should citizens pay proper taxes?
Related to this, 1Sambayan noted: “P203 billion is too much public money to lose to silence, inaction, or administrative neglect.”
- Latest
- Trending














