'Why the rush?': House says Senate buried impeachment too soon despite SC appeal pending

MANILA, Philippines — "Why the rush?"
This was the question posed by House Speaker Martin Romualdez after the Senate voted on Wednesday, August 6, to archive the articles of impeachment against Vice President Sara Duterte.
House leaders expressed disbelief over how swiftly the upper chamber adopted the amended motion of Sen. Rodante Marcoleta, which sought to archive the impeachment based on the July 25 Supreme Court ruling.
"To archive is, in effect, to bury the Articles of Impeachment. Yet the ruling of the Supreme Court is not final," Romualdez said in a statement on Thursday, August 7.
Nineteen senators voted to archive the complaint, with four opposing and one abstaining.
While House Deputy Majority Leader Zia Alonto Adiong said the Senate's action comes as no surprise, he and other House officials questioned why most senators simply brushed aside the House’s motion for reconsideration still pending before the high court.
"It came not as a surprise para sa akin considering the political alignments in the Senate," Adiong said at a press conference on Thursday.
"Mayroon na pong intention really to dismiss. It was to me, there's some sort of revelation because they acted it on a very very swift action, considering sinabi nga the fact there is no final judicial conclusion," he added.
The Supreme Court declared the impeachment proceedings unconstitutional, ruling that the Senate could not acquire jurisdiction due to the one-year bar rule and lack of due process. The Court also said its decision was immediately executory — but not final.
According to Romualdez, this proves the case is far from over, especially as the Supreme Court has required the parties to file their responses to the House’s motion for reconsideration, which challenges the ruling and alleges factual misstatements.
RELATED: House moves to reverse Supreme Court ruling on Sara Duterte's impeachment
Rejecting claims that the fourth complaint was rushed, House Speaker Martin Romualdez argued that it was the Senate that hastily moved to lay the impeachment to rest.
It was this complaint, endorsed by 215 House members, whose articles of impeachment were transmitted to the Senate.
"The filing of the complaint was not rushed. What was rushed — remarkably — was its burial," he said in a statement on Thursday.
Beyond technical and procedural concerns, the House leaders stressed the impeachment involves allegations of bribery, graft and corruption, betrayal of public trust, and culpable violations of the Constitution.
The bigger picture, Adiong and Chua remind, is public accountability.
A premature move
Rep. Joel Chua, chair of the House Committee on Good Government and Public Accountability, found the Senate’s sudden urgency ironic, given that it took four months to act on the impeachment.
Although the Senate recognized its authority to defy the Supreme Court ruling as a co-equal branch, Chua said the impeachment still arrived at the same outcome, similar to when the impeachment articles were sent back to the House over alleged legal infirmities.
The Senate’s lone session as an impeachment court took place on June 10, a day before its sine die adjournment.
Sen. Bato dela Rosa moved to dismiss the complaint, but with Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano’s intervention, the motion was revised to “remand” the articles to the House — a move some noted was unusual, given that the House is not a lower court.
It was also Cayetano who proposed revising Marcoleta’s motion by replacing “dismiss” with “archive.” According to Senate President Chiz Escudero, who was among the 19 senators who voted in favor, the impeachment complaint could still be revived by a Senate vote.
Despite expressing disapproval over the archiving of the articles of impeachment, Chua and Adiong believe it was still a better outcome than an outright dismissal.
Adiong, however, maintained that the articles would have best been tabled instead of archived to make it easier for the Senate to retrieve the complaint, if necessary.
He explained that the Senate would have to vote to retrieve the articles from the archives should the Supreme Court reverse its ruling.
If that’s the case, Chua believes the Senate should vote unanimously to retrieve the articles, since the original motion to archive was based solely on the high court's decision.
'Fight is not over'
The concept of archiving the articles of impeachment, however, has been interpreted differently by lawmakers. Sen. Risa Hontiveros and Senate Minority Leader Tito Sotto argued during the over six-hour session on Wednesday that it would effectively kill the impeachment case.
Rep. Chel Diokno echoed a similar sentiment, saying “the Senate hammered another nail in the coffin of accountability.”
Rep. Leila de Lima (ML Party-list), however, cited former Justice Antonio Carpio in contending that archiving leaves the door open for revival, suggesting that the pursuit of accountability is not yet over.
"The fight goes on. Hindi pa tapos ang laban. Kapit lang," she said.
For many lawmakers, the Senate’s decision reflects a denial of due process to the Filipino people, but the battle isn’t over.
The Supreme Court has yet to rule on the pending motion for reconsideration, which also seeks to correct the factual errors behind its original ruling.
- Latest
- Trending



























