DOJ prosecutors stand by Gracias no-collusion testimony
August 1, 2004 | 12:00am
Government prosecutors handling the kidnapping case against the Abu Sayyaf bandit group are standing firm on the testimony of American missionary Gracia Burnham that she had no knowledge of the alleged collusion between the military and her former captors over ransom payments.
Acting Justice Secretary Merceditas Gutierrez said the prosecutors would secure a copy of the transcript which detailed Burnhams testimony during the closed-door court hearing at Camp Bagong Diwa in Taguig last Thursday.
"The prosecutors were there and that was (what) they reported to me. I think they can defend their declarations because they were there and listened to Mrs. Burnham. I dont see any reason why they will distort the truth. They were only saying what they heard," Gutierrez said.
On the other hand, opposition Sen. Aquilino Pimentel Jr. said Gutierrez must make public the transcripts to determine the exact statements made by Burnham.
Pimentel earlier claimed Burnham contradicted herself in her testimony when she cleared the military of accusations of collusion with the Abu Sayyaf bandits.
Pimentel claimed Burnham backtracked from what she wrote in her book "In the Presence of My Enemies," detailing some incidents of alleged collusion between her former captors and the military.
In her book, Burnham describes her and her late husbands 377-day ordeal at the hands of the Abu Sayyaf and cites several instances where the bandits made contact with alleged military negotiators.
"The claim that Burnham allegedly cleared the military of collusion with the Abu Sayyaf was a contradiction of what she wrote in her book," Pimentel said yesterday.
Although the court may dismiss Burnhams accounts in her book as a hearsay evidence, Pimentel said it can be considered an exemption to the rule, depending on the "evaluation of circumstances."
At the same time, Pimentel said Malacañang made a deceptive move of thanking Burnham for clearing the military from accusations of collusion.
"I am certain that Gracia Burnham did not have any opportunity at all to say that the military was cleared of any collusion with the Abu Sayyaf in the matter of her kidnapping and that of her husband," Pimentel told the Kapihan sa Sulo Hotel forum in Quezon City.
"The prosecution purposely did not touch that issue because, I understand, the matter of issue was the kidnapping and not the collusion between certain military officers and the Abu Sayyaf," Pimentel added.
State Prosecutor Nestor Lazaro disclosed his personal observation that Burnham made the answer after she was questioned by defense lawyers during the three-hour closed door hearing about the alleged collusion between the military and her captors.
Lazaro explained the government prosecutors objected to the line of questioning made by the defense panel since the issue of collusion is not material to the kidnapping case.
Burnham flew back to the Philippines last week for a court appearance to testify against her kidnappers, two years after the ordeal that claimed the life of her husband Martin.
She went through an emotional three-hour testimony at a closed-door trial at a special court in Taguig where she positively identified six of eight Abu Sayyaf defendants as among a group that abducted them and 18 other tourists in a plush resort in Palawan on May 27, 2001.
But despite the objections by the prosecution, Lazaro claimed Burnham went on to answer the question thrown to her by defense lawyers, clearing the military from any collusion with her former abductors.
"Everything is on the record anyway, the judge had the testimony on video and tape. She said it under oath. She was no longer able to elaborate," Lazaro said. "Her remark, given under oath, in open court should clarify any uncertainties."
Pimentel agreed that the prosecution was right in objecting to the line of questioning by the defense panel, particularly on the issue of collusion.
"I understand, the matter of issue was the kidnapping and not the collusion between certain military officers and the Abu Sayyaf," he said.
He said Burnham might have been briefed by the prosecutors to limit her testimony to identifying her abductors.
"What is unfortunate, however, is that, a deeper and graver issue, that of the role of some high ranking military officials have performed during the entire kidnapping incident of Gracia Burnham and her husband," Pimentel said.
He claimed television reports citing purported transcripts of Burnhams testimony were not enough proof that she cleared the military from accusations of collusion.
"I dont think there was any such testimony. And I want to challenge the President and (Presidential Spokesman Ignacio) Bunye to produce the transcript of Burnhams testimony," Pimentel said.
"It is difficult to believe what the President and Secretary Bunye are saying that Burnham has cleared the officers concerned. I dont think there was any clearance," he added.
Pimentel said the controversy would not have happened if only the media were allowed to cover Burnhams testimony.
Pimentel said the ban on media coverage made the court proceedings more questionable. He said the media ban was also a breach of the freedom of the press and the right of people to information.
Pimentel maintained the Senate investigation of the issue tended to support the allegation that certain military officers connived with the Abu Sayyaf.
"Fr. Cirilo Nacorda, parish priest of Lamitan, Basilan even offered to present 20 witnesses who could testify on the alleged collusion especially the handling of the ransom money," Pimentel said.
Burnham, for her part, urged her hosts Friday to "do what is right" in the battle against terrorism.
She said in a brief statement read to the press before boarding a flight back to the United States that she had returned to take the witness stand because "I felt that was one thing I could do to make this country and this world a better place."
Burnham added, "as we all do what is right, we will see our world change."
"How I love this country. How I miss its beauty and its people. How I would love to see your fair land free from terror. It is the wish of so many of us and it is a most worthy goal," said the widow.
"Life for me the last few years has often been a struggle," the mother of three said. "Im learning what single parenting is all about."
President Arroyo earlier Friday praised Burnhams courage for testifying against her former captors.
Mrs. Arroyo said the trial of the eight alleged Abu Sayyaf kidnappers "is living proof of our determined fight against terror in partnership with all nations and peoples." -With Mike Frialde, Sandy Araneta, AFP
Acting Justice Secretary Merceditas Gutierrez said the prosecutors would secure a copy of the transcript which detailed Burnhams testimony during the closed-door court hearing at Camp Bagong Diwa in Taguig last Thursday.
"The prosecutors were there and that was (what) they reported to me. I think they can defend their declarations because they were there and listened to Mrs. Burnham. I dont see any reason why they will distort the truth. They were only saying what they heard," Gutierrez said.
On the other hand, opposition Sen. Aquilino Pimentel Jr. said Gutierrez must make public the transcripts to determine the exact statements made by Burnham.
Pimentel earlier claimed Burnham contradicted herself in her testimony when she cleared the military of accusations of collusion with the Abu Sayyaf bandits.
Pimentel claimed Burnham backtracked from what she wrote in her book "In the Presence of My Enemies," detailing some incidents of alleged collusion between her former captors and the military.
In her book, Burnham describes her and her late husbands 377-day ordeal at the hands of the Abu Sayyaf and cites several instances where the bandits made contact with alleged military negotiators.
"The claim that Burnham allegedly cleared the military of collusion with the Abu Sayyaf was a contradiction of what she wrote in her book," Pimentel said yesterday.
Although the court may dismiss Burnhams accounts in her book as a hearsay evidence, Pimentel said it can be considered an exemption to the rule, depending on the "evaluation of circumstances."
At the same time, Pimentel said Malacañang made a deceptive move of thanking Burnham for clearing the military from accusations of collusion.
"I am certain that Gracia Burnham did not have any opportunity at all to say that the military was cleared of any collusion with the Abu Sayyaf in the matter of her kidnapping and that of her husband," Pimentel told the Kapihan sa Sulo Hotel forum in Quezon City.
"The prosecution purposely did not touch that issue because, I understand, the matter of issue was the kidnapping and not the collusion between certain military officers and the Abu Sayyaf," Pimentel added.
State Prosecutor Nestor Lazaro disclosed his personal observation that Burnham made the answer after she was questioned by defense lawyers during the three-hour closed door hearing about the alleged collusion between the military and her captors.
Lazaro explained the government prosecutors objected to the line of questioning made by the defense panel since the issue of collusion is not material to the kidnapping case.
Burnham flew back to the Philippines last week for a court appearance to testify against her kidnappers, two years after the ordeal that claimed the life of her husband Martin.
She went through an emotional three-hour testimony at a closed-door trial at a special court in Taguig where she positively identified six of eight Abu Sayyaf defendants as among a group that abducted them and 18 other tourists in a plush resort in Palawan on May 27, 2001.
But despite the objections by the prosecution, Lazaro claimed Burnham went on to answer the question thrown to her by defense lawyers, clearing the military from any collusion with her former abductors.
"Everything is on the record anyway, the judge had the testimony on video and tape. She said it under oath. She was no longer able to elaborate," Lazaro said. "Her remark, given under oath, in open court should clarify any uncertainties."
"I understand, the matter of issue was the kidnapping and not the collusion between certain military officers and the Abu Sayyaf," he said.
He said Burnham might have been briefed by the prosecutors to limit her testimony to identifying her abductors.
"What is unfortunate, however, is that, a deeper and graver issue, that of the role of some high ranking military officials have performed during the entire kidnapping incident of Gracia Burnham and her husband," Pimentel said.
He claimed television reports citing purported transcripts of Burnhams testimony were not enough proof that she cleared the military from accusations of collusion.
"I dont think there was any such testimony. And I want to challenge the President and (Presidential Spokesman Ignacio) Bunye to produce the transcript of Burnhams testimony," Pimentel said.
"It is difficult to believe what the President and Secretary Bunye are saying that Burnham has cleared the officers concerned. I dont think there was any clearance," he added.
Pimentel said the controversy would not have happened if only the media were allowed to cover Burnhams testimony.
Pimentel said the ban on media coverage made the court proceedings more questionable. He said the media ban was also a breach of the freedom of the press and the right of people to information.
Pimentel maintained the Senate investigation of the issue tended to support the allegation that certain military officers connived with the Abu Sayyaf.
"Fr. Cirilo Nacorda, parish priest of Lamitan, Basilan even offered to present 20 witnesses who could testify on the alleged collusion especially the handling of the ransom money," Pimentel said.
Burnham, for her part, urged her hosts Friday to "do what is right" in the battle against terrorism.
She said in a brief statement read to the press before boarding a flight back to the United States that she had returned to take the witness stand because "I felt that was one thing I could do to make this country and this world a better place."
Burnham added, "as we all do what is right, we will see our world change."
"How I love this country. How I miss its beauty and its people. How I would love to see your fair land free from terror. It is the wish of so many of us and it is a most worthy goal," said the widow.
"Life for me the last few years has often been a struggle," the mother of three said. "Im learning what single parenting is all about."
President Arroyo earlier Friday praised Burnhams courage for testifying against her former captors.
Mrs. Arroyo said the trial of the eight alleged Abu Sayyaf kidnappers "is living proof of our determined fight against terror in partnership with all nations and peoples." -With Mike Frialde, Sandy Araneta, AFP
BrandSpace Articles
<
>
- Latest
- Trending
Trending
Latest
Trending
Latest
Recommended
























