Robbery in Monterrey

SPORTING CHANCE - Joaquin M. Henson - The Philippine Star

Zamboanga del Nortes Rene Mark Cuarto wouldve retained the IBF minimumweight title instead of losing it to hometowner Daniel Valladares on a disputed split 12-round decision in Monterrey, Mexico, last Friday night (Saturday morning, Manila time) if only Arizona referee Wes Melton ruled a knockdown in the eighth round and didnt deduct a point for a questionable violation of delaying the fight to fix loose tape on the Filipinos glove.

Heres how the judges scored it. Filipino Jonathan Davis, whos based in California, saw it 116-111 for Valladares. He awarded four rounds to Cuarto, including the eighth. Another Californian, Daniel Sandoval, tallied 114-113 for Cuarto, giving him seven rounds. Joel Elizondo, a Texan, had it 116-112 for Valladares and scored the eighth round for the Mexican. Believe it or not, the three judges concurred in giving only one round for Cuarto and three for Valladares, indicating a strange disparity in scoring.

It appeared that Cuarto scored a knockdown in the eighth round. Cuarto said a left uppercut dropped Valladares and saw it from close range. Cuartos trainer Nonoy Neri said it was a combination capped by the uppercut that sent Valladares down. MP Promotions head Sean Gibbons, watching at ringside, said it was a clear knockdown. But Melton ruled it a slip. That took away what wouldve been a 10-8 round for Cuarto. Curiously, Elizondo scored it 10-9 for Valladares while the two other judges had it 10-9 for Cuarto. Then, in the 10th round, Melton slapped a point deduction on Cuarto after leading him to his corner to fix loose tape on the third occasion. Gibbons said it wasnt Cuartos fault that the temperature inside the arena was over 100 degrees, making the tape moist and loose. In over 30 years of involvement in boxing, Gibbons said it was the first time he witnessed a point deduction on a fighter for fixing loose tape on his glove. In the official scorecard, it was noted that Melton “discounted a point on Cuarto due to bandages falling off too many times.”

If a knockdown was called, Elizondo wouldve scored the eighth round 10-8 for Cuarto and not 10-9 for Valladares. If Melton hadnt deducted a point, Elizondos scorecard wouldve been 114-114. In that eventuality, only Davis scored it for Valladares meaning Cuarto wouldve retained the crown by a split draw.

In the fourth round, Valladares suffered cuts over both eyes and on his scalp. An accidental headbutt caused a gash over the right eye and another, the scalp wound. Neri said a punch opened a nasty cut over the left eye. Melton gave no indication if the ugly cut was inflicted by a butt so the assumption was it was caused by a blow. Twice, Melton called the ringside physician to examine Valladarescut. If the doctor recommended a stoppage and Melton waved it off, Cuarto wouldve won by a TKO. Although blood flowed profusely from the cut and the doctor appeared close to suggesting a halt, Melton stood his ground. The fight wouldnt be stopped so it could go to the scorecards with the judges taking care of the verdict.

Gibbons said the ringside physician did a good job of treating Valladarescut. “The doctor worked on the cut and cleaned it better than any cutman couldve,” said Gibbons. “Once, the referee didnt ask the doctor to come up but he went on his own. I will email IBF president Daryl Peoples. The referee blew the knockdown and the point deduction for the loose tape was ridiculous.” Gibbons said hell exercise the option in Cuartos fight contract and arrange a rematch, surely not in Mexico. Cuarto wont be robbed a second time.


  • Latest
  • Trending
Are you sure you want to log out?

Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!

or sign in with
no session for state
no session for code
no session for id_token
no session for user