Barili hospital deaths spark row
CEBU, Philippines — Calls for answers from grieving families over reported incidents at the Barili District Hospital have sparked a public exchange between 3rd District Rep. Karen Garcia and Cebu Provincial Government health consultant Dr. Nikki Catalan.
The exchange followed Garcia’s call for the provincial government through the Integrated Provincial Health Office (IPHO) to expedite its investigation into the deaths of a mother and her unborn child, as well as other complaints involving the hospital’s personnel and services.
In a public statement, Garcia said her office had received several complaints and concerns about the Capitol-run hospital.
“Among nadawat, nadungog, nabasa, ug nasabtan ang mga nagsunod-sunod nga reklamo ug kabalaka bahin sa personnel ug services sa Barili District Hospital,” Garcia said.
She extended her condolences to the families who lost their loved ones, acknowledging the pain and difficulty brought by the incidents.
Garcia specifically urged the IPHO, which supervises the hospital, to expedite its investigation into the death of a pregnant woman diagnosed with placenta previa and her unborn child.
She also called for the review to cover the reported death of another newborn and a separate complaint from a patient who claimed she was turned away after the hospital's cut-off time and that the facility lacked a complete blood count (CBC) test and other laboratory services.
“We respectfully hope nga mapaspasan sa IPHO ang ilang gihimong investigation sa kaso sa inahan nga adunay placenta previa ug namatay uban sa iyang anak,” Garcia said.
She stressed that the concerns should be examined fairly and thoroughly, taking into account both the affected families and the healthcare workers involved.
“Importante nga mapaminaw ang tanan ug matubag ang mga pangutana aron makatabang sa pagpalambo sa serbisyo para sa atong komunidad,” she added.
In response, Catalan, the provincial government's consultant on health and hospital reform, presented figures on the hospital's workforce, patient load and available services.
Catalan said the 25-bed infirmary had only 58 personnel when her mother, Gov. Pamela Baricuatro assumed office, including two full-time doctors and 17 nurses. By July 2026, the provincial government had hired 57 additional personnel, bringing the workforce to 115. These included nine doctors, 28 nurses, 14 midwives and nursing attendants, 18 allied health personnel, 21 administrative and clerical staff, and 25 support and utility workers.
From January to September 2026, the hospital handled 25,212 admissions and consultations, including 1,532 inpatient admissions, 7,300 emergency room consultations and 16,380 outpatient consultations.
Catalan said the hospital laboratory, which did not operate around the clock before July 2025, now provides 24-hour service. As of Nov. 15, it had conducted 4,960 tests for the year.
Despite these improvements, she said the hospital continues to operate beyond its intended capacity, with inpatient bed utilization at 124 percent and emergency room utilization at 230 percent.
“Our doctors, nurses, and medical and nonmedical staff are doing their best to serve your constituents under these conditions,” Catalan said, adding that she would personally defend hospital personnel against judgments made before the facts are established.
“Every life is precious, and every complaint about patient care deserves to be taken seriously,” she added.
Catalan reminded Garcia how the previous administration had neglected the provincial healthcare system, stressing that rebuilding it would take time.
Catalan also raised concerns over the Medical Assistance for Indigent and Financially Incapacitated Patients (MAIFIP), claiming that the Barili District Hospital had not received an assistance allocation since September 2025.
Citing information from provincial social workers, she urged Garcia to help address what she described as a gap in financial assistance for patients seeking medical support.
“Congresswoman, this is your district, too,” Catalan said.
Garcia, however, clarified that her office had already provided assistance to patients and families who sought help, including those from outside the Third District and even Cebu City.
She said her office had also coursed assistance through the Barili Infirmary, a municipal government-run facility, recognizing its need for support alongside the provincial government's resources for the district hospital.
In her response, Garcia stressed that her concerns were not about assigning blame to hospital personnel but about seeking answers for families who had lost loved ones.
“The issue we hope to address is not simply the number of personnel, consultations, or services available. It is the loss of lives, the questions of grieving families, and the need to understand whether there were gaps in care, and whether anything could have been done differently,” she said.
She added that the MAIFIP issue should not divert attention from the reported deaths and other patient complaints, which she said were separate concerns.
One of the cases cited by Garcia involved Angelle Fe Isugan, who died with her unborn child after being brought to the Barili District Hospital on Nov. 4.
Her husband, Jhovell Patlingrao, said in a video posted on social media that he rushed his wife to the hospital after she suffered severe bleeding.
Patlingrao alleged that hospital personnel performed an internal examination despite his wife's prenatal records indicating she had placenta previa. He questioned why the procedure was conducted and why her referral to a higher-level hospital took time as her condition deteriorated.
Dr. Jenina Canoy, IPHO chief, earlier confirmed that it had launched an investigation into the incident and immediately required incident reports from the physician on duty and other medical personnel who attended to Isugan. The IPHO has yet to disclose the findings of its investigation.
Garcia maintained that her office was not drawing conclusions ahead of the investigation but was seeking a thorough and timely review to give the families answers.
She also clarified that her statement was not intended to attack doctors, nurses or other hospital personnel.
“Listening to patients and respecting healthcare workers are not opposing goals. Both are important to improving healthcare for everyone,” Garcia said.
She added that she remained open to revisiting the hospital and meeting with its personnel to discuss possible solutions.
“In the end, this is not about assigning blame before the facts are known. It is about listening to families, respecting our healthcare workers, seeking the truth, and doing what we can together to prevent avoidable loss of life,” Garcia said.
“There is no need to be defensive. We are all here to serve, and you can count on us for support,” she added. — /FPL (FREEMAN)
- Latest
















