EDITORIAL - ‘Confiscatory’

If the Marcos administration is trying to attract investments, it may want to study the planned auction of the country’s largest coal mine on Semirara Island in Antique, and the impact of new rules on business confidence.
The contract of Semirara Mining and Power Corp. to operate the mine expires in July 2027 and has not been extended. SMPC was granted a 35-year contract in 1977, which was extended for 15 years.
It sought another extension of 13 years, but the Department of Energy rejected it and announced a public bidding for a 25-year contract for the coal blocks. The DOE issued updated bidding rules, which SMPC publicly decried as “booby traps meant to discourage us from bidding.”
The complaint cannot be easily brushed aside, coming from one of the country’s largest diversified engineering and industrial conglomerates, DMCI Holdings Inc. of the Consunji Group.
Among other things, SMPC is protesting the “confiscatory” and “outright illegal” updated requirements for joining the upcoming auction. These include surrendering all its assets – not just the power plant and pier, but also movable assets such as hundreds of trucks and heavy equipment as well as proprietary know-how.
“At a time when the country is the focus of the whole world, here comes the DOE issuing this ill-advised, confiscatory and outright illegal provision apparently to keep us out of the bidding. Instead, this ill-timed requirement is telling prospective investors, many of whom are here now for the ASEAN summit, that the rule of law and policy stability do not exist here,” SMPC said in a statement.
SMPC said the new rules violate Presidential Decree 972 governing coal mining, which allows the company to remove its assets within one year of the expiration of the contract. All assets not recovered within that period become government property.
The company also bemoaned that the winning bid criteria has been changed, from technical and mining experience to the highest financial offer. The bids are due on Dec. 11 and any part of the bidding and award process cannot be challenged in court.
Amid rumors circulating that the new rules are designed to favor an administration crony, DOE officials have defended the rules and explained that these are meant to promote the nation’s energy security.
The issue may call for President Marcos and his economic managers to step in and decide what’s best for the country.
- Latest
- Trending














