PHO probing woman’s death at Barili hospital
CEBU, Philippines — The Cebu Provincial Health Office (PHO) said it is still investigatingan incident involving a pregnant woman who died following an alleged internal examination despite her reported diagnosis of placenta previa at the Barili District Hospital.
PHO chief Dr. JeninaCanoy said the office immediately required incident reports from the physician on duty and other medical personnel who attended to the woman.
Canoy said she had also personally spoken with one of the physicians involved during a recent activity in Barili. However, the PHO is still consolidating information and awaiting formal reports from the doctors and nurses.
The grieving husband, JhovellPatlingr, is seeking answers from the Barili District Hospital over the incident.
Patlingrao, in a video shared on social media, said he rushed his wife, Angelle Fe Isugan, to the hospital on Nov. 4 after she suffered severe bleeding. He alleged that hospital personnel performed an internal examination despite her prenatal records indicating placenta previa.
Patlingrao questioned why the procedure was performed and why her referral to a higher-level hospital took time as her condition continued to deteriorate.
Canoyconfirmed that Isugan was referred to the Cebu Provincial Hospital in Carcar, where an obstetrician-gynecologist (OB-GYN) was consulted for medical guidance.
According to Canoy, the Barili medical officer endorsed the case to the provincial hospital, which accepted the referral. However, the receiving hospital issued instructions before the patient could be transported.
"There were instructions prior to the transport, so ang OB naaygihatagngamga instructions and gisunodragyudsaatuangmga physicians on duty in Barili," Canoy said.
The PHO is now gathering accounts from the medical personnel involved and awaiting their formal incident reports to establish the circumstances surrounding her death.
In an interview, Patlingrao said he and his wife were asleep when he was awakened by her sudden bleeding. He found that she had already lost a considerable amount of blood and immediately sought help from relatives to secure an ambulance.
They arrived at the Barili District Hospital shortly after 5 a.m., where Isugan was brought to the labor room.
However, Patlingrao claimed they initially struggled to get assistance, saying no nurse was at the nurses' station when they arrived. He said he repeatedly asked the security guard for help until a nurse eventually came.
He also alleged that another nurse was asleep in a room and had to be awakened to attend to his wife.
While being attended to, Isugan reportedly complained of dizziness. Patlingrao said a nurse performed an internal examination and found that she was three centimeters dilated.
He alleged that another nurse conducted a subsequent examination, which caused his wife pain and was followed by heavier bleeding.
Patlingrao said he had already submitted his wife's prenatal records, which clearly indicated her placenta previa diagnosis.
"Ihatagnanakoang prenatal record so di natodapat e-IE kay nakabutangdidto Placenta previa," he said.
He also questioned the delay in referring his wife to the Cebu Provincial Hospital in Carcar, saying he repeatedly followed up with hospital personnel about transferring her to a facility with the necessary specialists.
According to Patlingrao, the baby's heartbeat was initially normal while his wife received medical intervention, including intravenous fluids and oxygen support. However, her breathing later became difficult and her blood pressure dropped.
As the bleeding continued, he recalled repeatedly asking when his wife would be transferred.
"Pertinangdaghanangdugo, luoynakaayonaakongasawa. Kanus-a man naninyo i-refer?" he recalled telling hospital personnel.
He said he was informed that his wife could not yet be transported because her blood pressure was unstable and needed to improve.
Patlingrao recalled that his wife's last words to him were, "Ayawkogbiyae."
As her condition worsened, he said he eventually asked the attending physician to intubate her in the hope of saving her life.
He claimed the unborn child was pronounced dead first, followed by his wife after hospital personnel could no longer detect the baby's heartbeat.
The husband said he remains convinced that something may have gone wrong in the hospital's handling of the case.
Awaiting a formal account
The PHO is also awaiting a formal account from the Carcar hospital detailing its assessment during the telephone consultation, including the medical instructions and management advised to the Barili medical team.
Canoy explained that the province has an internal referral arrangement among its 16 hospitals, allowing medical personnel in infirmaries to consult specialists at provincial hospitals for guidance in managing patients who may require higher-level care.
On the allegation that an internal examination was performed despite Isugan's reported placenta previa diagnosis, Canoy said the condition, which can be detected through ultrasound, generally involves painless vaginal bleeding.
She explained that internal examinations are generally avoided once placenta previa has been confirmed because of the associated risks.
"Kung identify gyudnasiya, and diagnose for placenta previa, which can be seen in ultrasound in whichever trimester of the pregnancy, so ma-avoided gyudnasiyaang internal examination," Canoy said.
However, she said the PHO is still verifying the medical records and information available to hospital personnel when Isugan arrived.
Based on initial information, Canoy said Isugan went directly to the hospital's emergency room and was not receiving prenatal care at the facility.
Her prenatal checkups were conducted through a rural health unit, while some laboratory tests were done at private institutions, she said.As a result, hospital physicians initially had to obtain her medical history and review the available test results upon her arrival.
Canoy added that the Barili medical officer consulted the provincial hospital's OB-GYN, who provided instructions that included conducting an internal examination.
The PHO said it would continue gathering information to establish the sequence of events and determine whether the medical management and referral process were properly carried out.
The investigation remains ongoing pending the complete incident reports and the receiving hospital's account.
- Latest



















