This opened up PSALM to allegations it disqualified La Costa to help bidders with lower offers bag the deal Salvador “Buddy” Zamora II has a simple approach to enterprise valuation that was very easy for his lawyer to explain and even easier for the judge to understand.
The younger brother to businessman Manuel Zamora Jr. and House Minority Leader Ronaldo Zamora filed a suit last month questioning his company’s disqualification from bidding for the National Transmission Co. (Transco).
Two weeks before the Dec. 12 auction for Transco, which was won by a group led by Monte Oro Grid Resources with a $3.95-billion bid, Zamora’s lawyer told a Makati court that the disqualified bidder had intended to make a $6-billion offer. That was more than half the winning bid and twice the estimated value of Transco’s assets.
When asked how the figure was arrived at, Napoleon Poblador, Zamora’s lawyer, explained that his client just multiplied $400 million, Transco’s average net revenue in the last four years, by 15 years, what Zamora believed was the bid payment period.
Finance professionals are likely to find Zamora’s approach too straightforward for their taste. Said one: “What about the time value of money? A dollar tomorrow is not the same as $1 today. You just can’t add them up without discounting money yet to be earned in the far future.”
Highest bid
Experts may dismiss Zamora’s simple approach to valuation but the disclosure of his $6-billion bid ahead of the auction worked to draw public sympathy to his company, La Costa Development Corp., which was disqualified by the Power Sector Assets and Liabilities Management Corp. (PSALM), the state agency in charge of privatizing Transco. PSALM said La Costa failed to show proof of financial capability.
It also gave a new twist to his dispute with PSALM. The issue is now no longer just whether officials were fair or unfair in applying the rules on financial prequalification to La Costa but if the decision resulted in substantial injury to the government by barring a bidder who was prepared to submit what turned out to be the highest bid. It opened up PSALM to allegations it disqualified La Costa to help other bidders with substantially lower offers bag the deal.
In an interview with The Philippine Star, Rep. Teodoro Locsin said this is one of the issues that Congress will look into when it considers Monte Oro’s application for a public utility franchise. “At the pre-qualification process there can be collusion (among bidders and government officials).
They can agree to (peg the price at) $3.95 billion and disqualify a $6-billion bid by saying it’s maverick, you strike that out,” Locsin was quoted by The STAR as saying.
Public debate on true value of Transco
Many questions surround Zamora’s intended bid but he can at least be credited for starting the ball rolling on a public debate on how much Transco is really worth, and whether the government could have gotten much more for it.
Zamora happens to believe that Transco is actually worth much more than the $6 billion he intended to bid for it. “It’s a conservative figure,” his lawyer told Newsbreak in a phone interview. “It does not take into account the six percent annual growth in demand or the collateral telecoms business” from Transco’s fiber optic cables, according to Poblador.
Zamora thinks Transco will be able to pay for itself after less than two decades.
“It’s all gravy after the 15th year,” he told Newsbreak.
Two things are often cited in support of this view. First, Transco has had a very profitable run so far. Its net income reached P19.5 billion last year and P16.2 billion the year before, in part because it is debt-free. All transmission-related liabilities amounting to $2.7 billion were retained by the insolvent National Power Corp.
Second, the winning bidder is given the option to pay three-quarters of the bid on installment over 20 years.
Opposition senator Jamby Madrigal said Monte Oro is practically getting Transco “without cost,” according to The STAR. “The people involved here appear to have won the sweepstakes. No matter how you look at it, it was given away. It’s like winning more than the jackpot,” The STAR quoted her as saying.
Not a walk in the park
But making money from the 25-year Transco concession agreement is not as easy as Zamora or Madrigal make it to be, according to PSALM and Transco officials interviewed by Newsbreak.
For one, the installment payments come with interest, which is based on a benchmark coupon rate on 10-year government bonds plus 230 basis points.
That comes up to around 8.8 percent, according to the rates posted by the Philippine Dealing and Exchange Corp. as of Dec. 14.
Assuming this interest rate holds true for the next 20 years, annual bid payments could reach $320 million for Monte Oro and $486 million for La Costa in the next two decades.
But there is another major expense item to consider. Under the terms of the concession agreement, the winning bidder is required to make fixed investments, set by the Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC) once every five years, for expansion and upgrading of facilities. For 2006-2010, Transco was required to spend $725 million or roughly $145 million a year.
Based on these parameters, the $400 million that Transco is expected to earn annually in the next 15 years would not be enough to cover the bid amortization required for capital expenditures of either Monte Oro or La Costa.
It’s highly possible for the private concessionaires to make money on Transco but it won’t be a walk in the park. Profit growth will have to come from cost cutting, efficiency gains or better management of capital expenditures rather than from growth in sales volume or higher tariffs, power officials warn. Transco’s revenues are allowed to go up by only 5.1 percent per year, the projected inflation rate, between 2006 and 2010.
Regulated industry
Revenues are capped by energy regulators so Transco, unlike other regulated public utilities, does not really benefit from higher rates or bigger business volume. Its average rates go up or down depending on sales volume but the company’s maximum allowable revenue remains the same.
A key to revenue and profit growth is faster implementation of transmission expansion and upgrading projects. This adds to the regulatory asset base, against which regulators multiply the weighted average cost of capital to determine Transco’s maximum allowable revenue for any given year. The higher the asset base, the higher the revenue.
Right now, Transco officials say the pace of capital expenditures is hampered by complicated government procurement rules that often result in failed biddings. Of the P9.9-billion capital expenditures planned for 2006, only P6.7 billion pushed through. That delays projects while increasing costs.
“By the time you hold the second or third bidding, prices would have gone up,” said a Transco official. “Hopefully, the private concessionaires can decide and move much faster than us.”
Risks and pressures
Still, power industry insiders believe PSALM could have gotten more for Transco if only there were less regulatory and political risks. They believe that uncertainties in rate-setting and the prospect of the winning bidder having to secure a franchise from Congress have somehow dampened the bids for the concession agreement.
The Energy Regulatory Commission has established a framework which allows Transco to earn returns of up to 15.9 per cent of its regulatory asset base annually between 2006 and 2010. However, actual returns have fallen to just 10.4 per cent last year because regulators imposed so-called “side constraints” that limited tariff increases below what is called for under the regulatory framework.
“The bidders saw that Transco was earning returns less that what it was entitled to under the regulatory framework adopted by the ERC and that may have prompted them to discount their bids,” said a Transco executive.
Another power official said the bids may have been pulled down because the concession agreement did not come with a public utility franchise from Congress, exposing the winning bidder to all sorts of pressures when it applies for one.
“Without that, they could have easily made a bid of at least $4.5 billion for Transco,” guessed the official.
If true, that’s a cost that the government seems prepared to bear. The alternative is a stalled power privatization program that will surely cost the economy even more. (www.newsbreak.com.ph)