"Stop beating a dead horse!" an exasperated Presidential Spokesman Ignacio Bunye said. "As I said (Tuesday), the Palace position remains the same, have mercy on the horse."
Bunye yesterday said Malacañang is not in any way interfering with the affairs of the Senate. "But we also know that there are other priority programs that perhaps need more attention from them," he said.
Lawmakers, for their part, pointed out the need to settle the question of collusion once and for all. And if the case is reopened, according to Sen. Rodolfo Biazon, American missionary Gracia Burnham should return to the country and clarify the issue.
Biazon told the weekly Citio Fernandina forum yesterday that the testimony of Burnham is vital in proving the allegations of collusion. "If there should be another investigation, there is a need for Burnham to appear and testify. We might request her to be available," Biazon said in Filipino.
Biazon, who chaired the Senate committee on defense during the 12th Congress, was among those who opposed the reopening of the Senate probe over the alleged collusion as suggested by Sen. Sergio Osmeña III.
Among those who opposed the reopening of the case were Senators Panfilo Lacson, Edgardo Angara and Ramon Magsaysay Jr., who all said the Senate has other important matters to take up than resurrecting the Lamitan incident.
The Senate defense committee headed by Biazon had recommended the court martial of several military officers led by Lt. Gen. Romeo Dominguez, who was in charge of the rescue operations in Lamitan, Basilan.
The military made a separate investigation over the incident but subsequently cleared the officers of the charges. Dominguez was reassigned as commander of the Northern Luzon Command of the Armed Forces.
While he expressed apprehension over another investigation, Biazon stressed the need for the Armed Forces to clear its name. "The Armed Forces suffered a black eye because of this (collusion) accusations. We have to give our Armed Forces a break and prove that there was no collusion once and for all. This fact must be established," he said.
As part of a possible reopening of the investigation, Biazon said the Senate probe body must be furnished a copy of the stenographic notes detailing the testimony made by Burnham.
During a closed-door hearing last Thursday at Camp Bagong Diwa in Taguig, Burnham positively identified six of her former captors as among a group that abducted her and husband Martin along with 18 other tourists in a plush resort in Palawan on May 27, 2001.
Burnham, 45, flew back to the Philippines last week for a court appearance to testify against her al-Qaeda-linked kidnappers two years after the ordeal that claimed the life of her husband and fellow missionary. She wept as she described her ordeal and the killing of Martin during a military rescue operation on June 7, 2002.
But Biazon said it was unclear whether Burnham has cleared the military on the allegations of colluding with the bandits over ransom payments. "If there is a need for Gracia to personally appear before the Senate, I will personally invite her to come back," Biazon said.
Surigao del Sur Rep. Prospero Pichay and Cebu Rep. Robert Durano pointed out the prosecution of the Abu Sayyaf bandits was the reason why Burnham returned to the country to testify against her former captors.
Pichay said the House defense committee which he had presided during the 12th Congress had exhaustively investigated the circumstances surrounding the Lamitan incident, including the accusations of collusion. He pointed out that the committee had to conduct fact-finding trips in Basilan and Jolo.
Pichay said the committee findings, which were affirmed by the plenary session of the House, showed no evidence of collusion although it affirmed the payment of ransom to the Abu Sayyaf.
"The alleged collusion should not muddle the real issue which is the crimes committed by the (Abu Sayyaf). What is important is for the captured Abu Sayyaf bandits to pay for their crimes and for the court to give justice to their victims," Pichay said.
Among the recommendations made by the committee was for the military to correct several lapses in dealing with the bandit group, he said.
For his part, Durano said it is best to put the collusion issue to rest. "We should move on and just await completion of the court hearings on (their) crimes," said Durano, chairman of the House committee on public order and security which also investigated the incident.
Durano said the House has done its part in investigating the truth behind the Lamitan siege, even as the military also made an investigation over the issue.
A former lawmaker also defended his erstwhile colleagues in the investigation made by the House over the incident.
Zamboanga City Mayor Celso Lobregat said the House committee members found out for themselves the lapses of the military in dealing with the Abu Sayyaf but no evidence of collusion ever surfaced. - With Mike Frialde, Aurea Calica, Roel Pareño