‘Gracia contradicted herself’

American missionary Gracia Burnham contradicted herself in her testimony Thursday when she cleared the military of accusations of collusion with her Abu Sayyaf kidnappers, opposition Sen. Aquilino Pimentel Jr. said yesterday.

Pimentel claimed Burnham backtracked from what she wrote in her book "In the Presence of My Enemies," which he said detailed some incidents of collusion between her former captors and the military.

In her book, Burnham describes her and her late husband Martin’s 377-day ordeal at the hands of the Abu Sayyaf and cites several instances where the bandits made contact with alleged military negotiators, Pimentel said.

"I read her book and what she was supposed to have told the court was contrary to her account. The general perception from her book was that there was a military-Abu Sayyaf collusion," Pimentel told the weekly Balitaan sa Rembrandt Hotel in Quezon City yesterday.

Burnham wrote that soldiers once brought food to the hostages and their captors because an unidentified military general was trying to arrange a 50 percent share of any ransom.

Negotiations by the general in the region — done partly with the help of a local radio station — fell through because the gunmen were willing to share only 20 percent, Burnham wrote in her book.

Pimentel said it was unlikely that Burnham would change her account. He said what was reported in the media about her testimony before s special court at Camp Bagong Diwa in Taguig last Thursday might be a "spin" initiated by certain groups to eventually clear some military officials.

The opposition lawmaker maintained Burnham’s account in her book made it very clear that there was a military-Abu Sayyaf connection.

Pimentel cited a part in the book where Burnham mentions an alleged cellular phone conversation by the bandit group with the military at the height of the Lamitan siege incident.

Burnham, 45, flew back to the Philippines this week for a court appearance to testify against her al-Qaeda-linked kidnappers two years after the ordeal that claimed the life of her husband Martin.

She went through an emotional three-hour testimony at a closed-door trial at a special court in Taguig where she positively identified six of eight Abu Sayyaf defendants as among a group that abducted them and 18 other tourists in a plush resort in Palawan on May 27, 2001.

She wept as she described her ordeal and the killing of her husband Martin, who was killed during a military rescue operation on June 7, 2002.
GMA Praises Burnham
On the other hand, President Arroyo praised Burnham for standing up against the Abu Sayyaf and clearing the military from accusations of collusion.

"I admire Gracia Burnham’s courage and faith and her determination to bring terrorists to justice," Mrs. Arroyo said.

"Her testimony also upholds the integrity and uncommon valor of our Armed Forces, and I thank her for her concern for our people’s peace and security," she added.

Mrs. Arroyo said the trial of the Abu Sayyaf gunmen who abducted Burnham "is living proof of our determined fight against terror in partnership with all nations and peoples."

Pimentel said the Supreme Court should make the proper appreciation of the testimony made by Burnham, as it may have set "a bad precedent" to any closed-door arrangements to take the testimony of witnesses.

"Nobody can prevent anyone from invoking the same (closed-door) privilege accorded to Burnham," he said.

Pimentel, who headed the Senate panel which investigated the incident, said there was enough evidence to show that there was collusion between the military and the Abu Sayyaf.

He gave weight to the testimony of Lamitan parish priest Fr. Cirilo Nacorda who claimed before the Senate hearing that some military men and the bandit group were in cahoots.

Nacorda alleged that money had changed hands during the Lamitan incident, triggering the investigation of the House and the Senate.

"Father Nacorda even brought with him several witnesses to back up their allegations," Pimentel said of the incident, wherein the bandits were able to escape a military dragnet.

There were suspicions that the bandits bribed the military in exchange for safe passage out of a Lamitan medical center where they were holed up. The military denied the allegations.

Nacorda, himself a former hostage, said the reason the military has been having difficulty wiping out the Abu Sayyaf was purely due to business.

The congressional investigations ended with conflicting results: The House of Representatives cleared the officers while the Senate panel said there was basis for suspicion.

Pimentel though clarified he is not accusing the rank and file of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) but only those within the ranks who "want to enrich themselves."

"I am not accusing the whole AFP, only a few officials who connived with the bandits," he said.
Exonerated
The President said Burnham’s testimony exonerated the AFP, some of whose officials were earlier alleged in the book written by Burnham to have colluded with the Abu Sayyaf bandits.

Justice Secretary Merceditas Gutierrez told reporters that Burnham had said in court that "she did not observe collusion between the Abu Sayyaf group and the military."

State prosecutor Leo Dacera said Burnham "also testified how the Abu Sayyaf deceived them into believing that they would be released after ransom was paid for them."

Most of the Filipino hostages were either ransomed off or escaped in batches; a third American, Peru-born Guillermo Sobero, was beheaded.

Dacera said Burnham also told the court how her kidnappers celebrated on hearing news of the Sept. 11 al-Qaeda attacks in the United States.

In her testimony, Burnham was quoted by Dacera as saying that her abductors, along with two Arab-looking men, celebrated in the jungle upon learning of the terror attacks in the US.

Surigao del Sur Rep. Prospero Pichay, chairman of the House committee that investigated the incident, said Burnham’s testimony confirmed their exhaustive report on the hostage crisis.

"We are grateful to Mrs. Burnham for helping vindicate the honor of the men and women of the Armed Forces, which was besmirched by the malicious allegations of traditional critics of the military and police in the aftermath of the kidnapping," Pichay said.

The Surigao lawmaker said Burnham’s testimony should put a stop to speculations that the military took a ransom cut in the negotiations with the Abu Sayyaf.

Pichay said the country and the military owes Burnham a debt of gratitude for setting the record straight.

Lt. Gen. Romeo Dominguez, along with several other officials who were accused of conniving with the Abu Sayyaf, also expressed thanks to Burnham for clearing their names.

Dominguez, now the commander of the Army Northern Luzon Command (Nolcom), said the supposed collusion was only a product of media interpretation of what actually occurred during the Lamitan siege incident.

Dominguez said he was not surprised by Burnham’s testimony since it confirmed the House committee findings.

"What Mrs. Burnham testified was in her book; the focus though in our media was their own biased interpretation," he said.

Interior and Local Government Secretary Angelo Reyes said the military has been vindicated by Burnham.

"We have been saying all along that the AFP was not in collusion with the Abu Sayyaf and that there was no truth to the accusations," said Reyes who was defense secretary when the accusations of collusion first surfaced.

For his part, Defense Undersecretary Ernesto Carolina, the former commander of the AFP Southern Command, said he was glad Burnham testified against the Abu Sayyaf and cleared the military.

Carolina likewise said Fr. Nacorda had tainted the military with his accusations.

He also lamented how Nacorda has been insisting that controversial Abu Sayyaf spokesman Abu Sabaya is still alive, contradicting claims by the military that he was killed in an encounter off the coast of Sibuco town in Zamboanga del Norte on June 21, 2002, two weeks after Gracia’s rescue.

"Damage has been done. Those military officers... have been subjected to all types of humiliating experiences like going through those trials and legislative hearings. Their names have been tainted," Carolina said.

"It is very good that Burnham came back and once and for all cleared them. Those officers were victims of circumstance," he said.

Carolina recalled seeing Burnham heave a sigh of relief after she was rescued. She was rescued by the military in "Operation Daybreak" in Sirawai, Zamboanga del Norte.

Carolina said the rescue operation took careful planning and strategy. "It was really the best efforts of our men in all units involved. You can just imagine the risks involved," he said.

The Abu Sayyaf attracted international attention with a yearlong kidnapping spree that began in May 2001. They eventually killed 18 of the 102 hostages they took.

Burnham’s book linked the Abu Sayyaf to Osama bin Laden’s al-Qaeda terrorist organization.

She said that in May 2001 — three months before the Sept. 11 attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon — her captors told her husband Martin to say in a ransom message that he was being held by "the Osama bin Laden group."

The Burnhams, longtime Christian missionaries in the Philippines, were kidnapped from a resort in Palawan, a day after they arrived to celebrate their 18th wedding anniversary.

The Abu Sayyaf also grabbed another American and 17 Filipinos, spiriting them away across 480 kilometers of sea to their hideout in Basilan.

The kidnappings prompted the United States to deploy American forces to help Filipino troops crush the bandit group and rescue the hostages. Washington also put up a $5-million bounty for the capture of the Abu Sayyaf’s top leaders, who were indicted in a US court the same year. - With Marichu Villanueva, Jaime Laude, Paolo Romero, Edith Regalado, AFP

Show comments