The real employee retention strategy

There is a common office joke about the boss who says, “My door is always open.” Employees often agree, watching colleagues leave through that very door.

Business owners often ask why it is difficult to find good people. A more important question is this: Why is it difficult to retain them? Exit interviews typically cite reasons such as “a better opportunity,” “career growth” or “personal reasons.” While these may be true, the underlying cause often relates to leadership, though few are willing to state it directly. This is why it is said that the two biggest lies are the curriculum vitae and the exit interview.

Gallup reports that managers account for about 70 percent of the difference in team engagement. Employees experience a company through their direct manager, not its vision statement or logo. On my YouTube podcast “Kongversations,” Charles Plumley, general manager of Great Place To Work® Philippines, emphasized this point.

The certification process relies on confidential employee surveys focused on trust, not self-assessment. To be certified, organizations must achieve at least 65 percent positive survey results. As Plumley notes, the best workplaces are those that “made a choice to give their people a voice.” This certification cannot be purchased or designed in a boardroom; it is earned through employee trust. Trust is not declared by leaders; it is determined by teams.

Where does trust go when it fades? Executive coach Marcel Schwantes, writing in Inc., observes that good employees rarely leave because of a single bad day. They leave after months of repeated leadership patterns.

Here are seven ways trust quietly erodes within a team.

First, Control. Micromanagement often stems from a fear that others will not meet expectations. Employees interpret constant oversight as a lack of trust. Over time, this leads them to seek opportunities elsewhere.

Second, Credit. Some leaders claim every team’s success as their own, while others overlook the daily efforts that sustain the business. Leaders who take all the credit will eventually be left to accept all the blame. To this day, some leaders still hold to this antiquated thinking: “If we praise our people too much, it may get into their heads, and they might expect an increase or promotions.” But credit given and compliments paid are rewards for a job already done well. Withholding them or, worse, grabbing the credit will certainly send people packing and looking for somewhere else to work.

Third, Silence. Some managers withhold information and only explain decisions when necessary. This lack of communication leads to rumors, which are often more damaging than the truth. While bad news can be unsettling, silence is even more so.

Fourth, Ego. Leaders who never admit mistakes create an environment where others are reluctant to be honest. As a result, issues are downplayed and open communication declines. When leaders refuse to acknowledge errors, teams stop providing valuable feedback.

Fifth, Forgetting the human being. Terms like manpower and headcount are useful, but it is important to remember that employees have families, ambitions and personal challenges. Machines require maintenance; people need to feel that someone genuinely cares.

Sixth, Avoidance. Some leaders put off hard feedback to keep the peace. What they actually keep is confusion. Problems rarely fix themselves; they grow. A fifteen-minute conversation today can spare you an HR case six months from now.

Seventh, and most important: Whom do i really serve? Schwantes identifies this as the underlying pattern. Some leaders view their role as a means to advance their own careers, while others see it as a responsibility to support their teams. Employees always recognize the difference.

None of these behaviors is dramatic. There is no shouting or scandal, only ordinary habits that, over time, shape the workplace culture. Good employees seldom walk away because of one bad Tuesday. They leave when too many Tuesdays begin to look exactly the same: trust withheld, credit taken, information hidden, mistakes denied, difficult conversations avoided and people treated as machinery rather than human beings. Turnover may eventually appear in an HR report, but its roots are often planted much earlier in everyday leadership behavior.

The encouraging news is that patterns can change. Trust can replace control, recognition can replace invisibility, honesty can replace silence and humility can replace ego. When leaders make these changes, talented employees do more than stay — they excel. Invest in leadership training, as many leaders have the title but lack the necessary skills and mindset to be effective.

Instead of asking, “How can my team help me succeed?” Consider, “What obstacles can I remove to help them succeed?” Addressing this question often resolves many other issues.

Before posting another job opening, reflect on your own leadership. The solution to retention challenges may lie within your approach. True leadership is measured not by the number of direct reports, but by how many people improve as a result of working with you.

Catch Kongversations with Francis on YouTube and all major podcast platforms: Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts and more. Plus, listen to Inspiring Excellence wherever you stream.

Show comments