All sides should talk
CEBU, Philippines — Cebu City Mayor Nestor Archival Sr. has expressed regret over the confrontation between police and protesters during an anti-Pax Silica rally in downtown Cebu, urging all sides to choose dialogue over division in its aftermath.
Archival issued a belated statement yesterday, a day after tensions flared along Colon Street during a protest that ended in a confrontation between demonstrators and policemen and sparked complaints from media groups over the treatment of journalists covering the event.
"The rally has concluded. I sincerely regret the unfortunate confrontation that took place," he said in a post.
The demonstration was part of a nationwide mobilization led by progressive organizations opposing the proposed Pax Silica initiative, a U.S.-backed effort aimed at strengthening global supply chains for semiconductors, artificial intelligence, and critical minerals.
In Cebu City, student groups, activists and members of various sectoral organizations marched through the city before converging along Colon Street to voice concerns over the project's implications on national sovereignty, economic policy, and the use of local resources.
The situation escalated after protesters burned an effigy of U.S. President Donald Trump, an act that authorities later cited as a public safety concern.
Videos and photographs shared online showed policemen with riot shields advancing toward demonstrators while authorities attempted to extinguish the burning effigy, resulting in a confrontation that drew criticism from rally organizers and media groups.
Despite the clash, Archival acknowledged both the demonstrators and law enforcement personnel involved in the incident.
"We recognize the citizens who exercised their right to express their views and concerns, as well as our police personnel who carried out their duty to maintain peace and order," he said.
He said the burning raised legitimate safety concerns that required police intervention, but emphasized that such actions must always be carried out within the bounds of professionalism and respect for human rights.
"The reported burning of an effigy raised public safety concerns that required police attention. Our police officers have a responsibility to enforce the law and protect the community. However, every action must always be guided by restraint, professionalism, and respect for human rights," Archival said.
He also suggested that heightened emotions among those involved may have contributed to the escalation.
"The tension and emotions during the incident may have contributed to the escalation. To everyone affected, I sincerely express my regret. Let this experience serve as a lesson, not a reason for further division," he said.
The incident prompted condemnation from the National Union of Journalists of the Philippines (NUJP) Cebu, which alleged that two unnamed journalists were injured while covering the protest.
According to the group, one journalist was struck by a police shield, while another inhaled powder from a fire extinguisher.
NUJP called on authorities to investigate the circumstances surrounding the incident and ensure the safety of journalists covering demonstrations.
In a separate statement, the Cebu City Police Office maintained that its personnel did not initiate violence and were only performing their duty to maintain public order and protect public safety.
The police said their personnel exercised maximum tolerance throughout the protest and allowed the assembly to proceed despite the absence of a permit.
It also defended its response to the effigy burning, arguing that the activity posed potential risks to motorists, pedestrians and protesters because of smoke, flying embers, and possible health hazards.
At the same time, the CCPO said it takes seriously the claims that journalists were hurt during the incident and is open to an impartial investigation.
Police officials also encouraged those involved to formally file complaints so their accounts could be properly heard.
Meanwhile, progressive organizations including the League of Filipino Students-Cebu and Bagong Alyansang Makabayan-Central Visayas condemned the police response and maintained that the demonstrators were exercising their constitutional right to peaceful assembly.
The groups vowed to continue opposing Pax Silica and other policies they believe undermine national interests.
Amid the competing narratives, Archival stresses the need to uphold both democratic freedoms and public safety, describing them as equally important in maintaining peace and order.
Calling for calm after the incident, he urged Cebuanos not to allow the confrontation to deepen divisions within the community.
"Let us choose dialogue over confrontation, understanding over anger, and unity over division," he said.
Archival concluded his statement by emphasizing the principles that should guide the city in moving forward from the incident.