^

Opinion

Ten years on, the Arbitral Award on the South China Sea matters

DIPLOMATIC POUCH - Massimo Santoro - The Philippine Star

Ten years ago, on July 12, 2016, an arbitral tribunal constituted under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) delivered a ruling that shaped the legal landscape of the South China Sea. The Arbitral Award, in the case brought by the Philippines against China, remains as relevant as ever.

That is not because it resolved every dispute in the South China Sea. It did not. Tensions have continued. Coercion has not ended. But the Award did something no show of force can erase: it established, with legal clarity and international authority, that maritime claims and conduct must be judged against law, not power. This is why the anniversary matters.

The South China Sea is not an abstract strategic concept. It is a source of food, livelihoods, energy, security for those countries touched by its waters. For the wider world, these waters are also very important, with trillions of dollars in trade passing through them each year. A significant part of the European Union’s trade in goods moves along this route. What happens in the South China Sea therefore affects regional stability, but also global commerce and supply chains.

Yet the real significance of the issue goes beyond economics. What is at stake is whether the rules the world has agreed upon still apply when they become inconvenient to the powerful. The European Union’s view is clear and consistent. UNCLOS remains the constitution of the oceans. It is the legal framework that governs maritime entitlements, protects freedom of navigation and overflight, supports the sustainable use of marine resources and provides mechanisms for the peaceful settlement of disputes. Without respect for UNCLOS, the maritime order becomes vulnerable to intimidation, coercion and instability.

The EU continues to affirm that the 2016 Arbitral Award is legally binding on the parties to the proceedings. The ruling must be respected. The EU considers that disputes must be handled peacefully, lawfully and without the threat or use of force. We strongly oppose any dangerous or coercive actions in the South China Sea, calling on all parties to exercise self-restraint and to resolve differences in accordance with international law.

Some may ask what difference a legal ruling makes if tensions persist: law matters most when it is under pressure. The Award reinforced a principle essential to every country, large or small: no State stands above the rules. It gave its parties and the international community a permanent legal reference point. It demonstrated that maritime entitlements cannot be expanded by assertion alone and that international law cannot simply be brushed aside when it proves inconvenient.

The Philippines’ support for international law in the maritime domain is matched by its wider support for multilateralism and for the rules-based international order. This consistency matters. It shows that the defense of a rules-based order cannot be selective.

It also shows why partnerships matter. To uphold the law, declarations need to be combined with action. The partnership between the EU and the Philippines has taken a significant step forward with the launch last year of the EU-Philippines Security and Defense Dialogue on the occasion of the visit to Manila of the EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy and Vice President of the European Commission, Kaja Kallas. Its first meeting, held in Brussels in November 2025, covered maritime security, cyber threats and FIMI (foreign information manipulation and interference). A second meeting is foreseen in Manila in October 2026.

High Representative Kaja Kallas is visiting the Philippines, for the second time, on July 22-24, 2026, in the context of the ASEAN Regional Forum under the Philippines’ Chairship. This will further underscore the strategic importance of this growing cooperation, both bilaterally and regionally. This matters because political dialogue creates channels for consultation, strategic understanding and closer coordination among partners facing shared challenges.

At the operational level, through the EU’s CRIMARIO (Critical Maritime Routes) initiative and its IORIS (Indo-Pacific Regional Information Sharing) platform, the Philippines’ civilian and maritime law enforcement agencies have improved real-time information-sharing and inter-agency coordination on illegal fishing, smuggling, piracy, marine pollution incidents and search-and-rescue operations, strengthening day-to-day maritime domain awareness. This practical cooperation also supports faster incident response, better coordination with regional partners and stronger institutional capacity in areas such as crisis management, coast guard cooperation and the protection of vital sea lanes. Through ESIWA+ (Enhancing Security Cooperation In and With Asia), the EU is supporting practical cooperation in areas such as maritime security, cyber resilience and crisis management. This is what support for a rules-based order looks like in practice: not rhetoric alone, but capability, coordination and preparedness.

The point of this cooperation is stability. It is to help ensure that disputes are managed peacefully, that incidents do not spiral and that the law is backed by institutions, partnerships and credible capacity.

Ten years after the Arbitral Award, the lesson is clear. International law does not enforce itself. It requires States to proactively defend it, invoke it and build coalitions around it. The 2016 ruling remains a milestone because it drew a legal line that pressure cannot erase. The task now is to ensure that this line continues to guide, conduct and shape diplomacy and inform international support.

*      *      *

Massimo Santoro is the Ambassador of the European Union to the Philippines.

SOUTH CHINA SEA

  • Latest
  • Trending
Latest
Latest
abtest
Are you sure you want to log out?
X
Login

Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!

Get Updated:

Signup for the News Round now

FORGOT PASSWORD?
SIGN IN
or sign in with