Hong Kong journalist convicted over database search for mob attack probe

Yan Zhao, Su Xinqi - Agence France-Presse
Hong Kong journalist convicted over database search for mob attack probe
Radio Television Hong Kong (RTHK) producer Bao Choy Yuk-ling (C) arrives at the West Kowloon Courts building in Hong Kong on April 22, 2021, for the verdict in her case where she has been charged with two counts of making false declarations under the Road Traffic Ordinance, while conducting vehicle registration searches for a documentary on the Yuen Long attacks that took place in July 2019.
AFP / Anthony Wallace

HONGKONG, China — An award-winning Hong Kong journalist was found guilty on Thursday of improperly searching a public vehicle licence database to help track down the perpetrators of an attack on democracy supporters by government loyalists.

The conviction of Bao Choy, a producer with public broadcaster RTHK, comes at a time of deepening concerns over press freedoms in the international business hub as Beijing stamps out dissent in the wake of huge democracy protests.

Choy, 37, was found guilty on two counts of "knowingly making a false statement" to access number plate ownership records.

"Members of the public do not have an absolute right to obtain any document under this ordinance," principal magistrate Ivy Chui said.

She faced up to six months in jail but was ultimately fined HK$6,000 ($770).

Colleagues and members of RTHK's employee union gathered outside the court holding banners that read "Journalism is not a crime" and "Who wants the public kept in the dark?"

"Though I was found guilty I still believe journalism is not a crime and searching registries is not a crime," Choy told reporters.

The database searches were made for an RTHK documentary last year called "Who Owns The Truth?" that investigated an attack on pro-democracy protesters by a gang of men armed with clubs and sticks.

The police's failure to respond quickly enough to the July 2019 assault was a turning point in the huge and often violent pro-democracy protests that year, further hammering public trust in the force.

RTHK used footage from witnesses and security cameras -- as well as number plate searches and interviews -- to piece together events.

It uncovered new details about the alleged attackers, some of whom have links to politically-influential rural committees that support Beijing.

It also said that police failed to respond to the build up of stick-wielding men ferried into the district by specific vehicles that evening hours before the attack.

'Dark day for Hong Kong'

Hong Kong maintains a publicly-accessible licence plate database long used by journalists, including pro-Beijing news outlets.

But authorities introduced a rule change that meant journalists were no longer allowed to make searches.

During her searches, Choy ticked a reason box that said "traffic and transportation related matters".

But Judge Chui ruled media reporting was not covered.

Choy's lawyers argued her searches served the public interest and helped Hong Kongers "get closer to the truth".

"Today is a dark day for Hong Kong journalists," Chris Yeung, head of the Hong Kong Journalists Association, said on Thursday. 

Authoritarian China heavily censors the media. 

But semi-autonomous Hong Kong remains a regional press hub with a vibrant local scene and many international outlets hosting regional headquarters.

But the city has slid down media freedom rankings in recent years.

Reporters Without Borders (RSF) now ranks Hong Kong as 80th in its annual global media freedom list, down from 18th in 2002.

Beijing has cracked down on opponents following 2019's protests, imposing a sweeping national security law and unveiling plans to ensure only "staunch patriots" run Hong Kong.

On Tuesday RSF warned China's "censorship virus" had spread to Hong Kong, adding that the security law was a "grave threat" to journalists.

The same day the city's police chief called for a "fake news law" to "assist national security".

Hong Kong's government dismissed RSF's report as "appalling".

Beijing has made no secret of its desire to see Hong Kong's critical media tamed and RTHK has increasingly found itself a government target.

Modelled on Britain's BBC, it is publicly funded and was editorially independent of Hong Kong's government.

Hong Kong's government has ordered an overhaul of the broadcaster, including the recent appointment of a career civil servant as its new head.

He has vowed to vet all programming and has pulled multiple shows, sometimes just days or hours before they were due to air.



  • Latest
  • Trending
Are you sure you want to log out?

Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!

or sign in with